Showing posts with label non-verbal communication. Show all posts
Showing posts with label non-verbal communication. Show all posts

Saturday, March 5, 2011

Non-Verbal Conversations: One Man Band

I have chosen non-verbal communication as my topic of choice in recent weeks. Non-verbal foundations of conversations are so important and are often overlooked and ignored when working with children with developmental delays.

One of our cable-TV channels is running a show of one Pixar short after another. One of my favorites, a bonus feature from the Cars DVD, is One Man Band.

I like it because One Man Band is such a wonderful reminder of what non-verbal conversations, attention shifting, attention sharing, look like, even though in this case, they're all animated.

Take a peek at it. I found the video here.

Friday, March 4, 2011

Verbal Faux-Interaction or Verbal Interaction? There is a difference.

The Among Friends blog features a post called "19 Ways to increase verbal interaction with your child" that I want to comment on, to add to. If you right click on the link to the Among Friends blog post and open it in another tab, you can see the list without closing this post.

In the blog post, speech-language pathologist Ruth HaberkornHalm gives parents a list of 19 actions to take in interactions with their children aimed at increasing verbal interactions with children who are in some sort of speech therapy. It's a great list, particularly when used for the right reasons (and I'm not convinced she's using them for the right reasons, based upon some of her descriptions), and I see uses for the list way beyond what she suggests.

HaberkornHalm writes, "In the treatment room, the speech pathologist teaches the child the skills needed to attain receptive and expressive language skills appropriate for their age or the highest level the child can reach." (I have a problem with part of this statement. Keep reading.)

She lists 19 ways, idea-starters that parents can use to create opportunities and situations for the kids to ask for something. She says, "They are designed to help the child use/increase requesting, verbal interaction and naming as well as improve speech intelligibility, expand utterances and build associations." I want to add the idea that the list of 19 is also designed to create opportunities for the child to wonder what is in Mom's mind, to wonder why she paused, why she left something out; to perspective take; to discover a problem or breakdown together and to repair it together.

If you look at that list, you can look at it two ways. In one way, it is a list designed to help parents to create opportunities for manding (requesting, or what I sometimes refer to as DEmanding), which is a term from behavioral psychology. If you look at it from another angle, it is a list of ways to build or grow interdependence, to create a situation where your child needs YOU for something, which may or may NOT involve "words" and "talk" and more importantly, is developmental and relational. I want, using Mom as a means to an end is drastically different from I need YOU to help me WITH something; let's do it together.

Interdependence is an important concept that is sometimes (often) missed in kids w/ developmental delays. A lot of kids with developmental delays and/or special needs don't know they NEED others; don't experience the benefits and importance of relationships with others.

HaberkornHalm sort of hints at this in the text, but does not go into detail: "They may have a hard time knowing what their child wants because he/she may not request, may not engage, their language is limited or intelligibility is compromised."

If your child fits the description of the first part of her list, they probably have no developmental business being made or expected in increase verbal interaction. If your child fits this descrption "They may have a hard time knowing what their child wants because he/she may not request, may not engage" then you may want to skip opportunities for your child to mand or request and instead use this list with a different goal in mind. (Hint: it's not "verbal interaction". Take some developmental steps back, please.)

Here's what I didn't understand, what no one explained to me when my child was two.


Giving children situations where they need to mand does not = relationship building.

There is a difference between creating opportunities for a child to mand as a means to an end VS creating opportunities to need you, to experience an "us", a "we", a "between you and me"that add up to relationships. If you seek engagement, relationship, "we", "us", "between you and me" experiences, please know this: Creating opportunities to mand won't get you where you want to go. Developmentally, you can't get there from here. Creating opportunities to practice and experience competent interdependence, opportunities to interact with reciprocity at non-verbal levels will get you there, and if you understand that developmental concept, you can use this sweet list on your trip.

Engagement at non-verbal levels comes first in development. Dr Gutstein taught me that words and talk are the last enhancement to an already complex system of engagement and interaction that add up to communication. If you are parenting a child who does not engage, give him experience in engagement at non-verbal levels and save pushing for verbal exchanges for the time when the non-verbal engagement, interaction, interdependence are in place.

The list is a great list, and can and SHOULD be used for other opportunities, particularly pre-speech, non-verbal foundations of relationships, for creating situations that you can do with your child.

I wish HaberkornHalm had established some sort of developmental criteria, some sort of developmental checklist for parents to help them know when using a list like hers for "verbal interaction" is developmentally appropriate.

Why is that so important to me? Because we were given lists like these to use for "verbal interaction" when my child did not have the non-verbal foundations of interaction and joint attention in place, first. The professionals guiding us understood behavior, but did not understand development. With hearts of gold and good intentions, we created more weirdness using a list like this one outside of a developmental framework.

"Verbal interaction" is not a developmentally appropriate goal for children who don't yet engage at non-verbal levels. If your child doesn't naturally need you, is not interdependent, if you have to create situations for your child to need your assistance, you may need to back up and give her some experience and practice at pre-verbal levels. If your child does not naturally need you, watch you, monitor you visually, and I'm talking referencing for meaning, not meaningless eye contact here; if you're not having rich non-verbal back-and-forth exchanges with your child, using this list to increase verbal interaction is probably developmentally inappropriate, no matter the age of the child. However, you can use this list to help your child experience pre-verbal foundations that lead to the verbal stuff.

So, first of all, in my laymom opinion, throw out the idea that goal is for the child to be "appropriate for their age". Throw out, "Modify the activity according to your child’s age and interests.", too. Let's try "developmentally appropriate" instead, and go from there.

Here's one good thing about the list for me: We parents can fall into a lifestyle of creating a lot of learned helplessness by doing too much for our kids, and a lot of HaberkornHalm's suggestions, in my opinion, are good reminders that we as parents should not do too much for our kids. Here's an example: HaberkornHalm suggests reminding your child to brush her teeth while hiding the toothpaste. When we give the child a toothbrush loaded with toothpaste, they get the message that they don't have to be engaged and active in self-care, that mom or dad will do most of the work for them. (See the labels section in my blog left-hand side bar for more thoughts on learned helplessness.)

Here's what I see differently from HaberkornHalm: The list of "19 ways", for me, though, isn't as much about verbal interaction as it is about stages of relationship development and joint attention. Her goal is "verbal interaction" and it differs from mine. My goal is relationship building. You can get "verbal interaction" and completely miss J/A and relationship building, or you can focus on relationship building and get J/A and interaction naturally along with it.

Parents of kids with developmental delays, or "special needs" or on the autism spectrum are often taught to miss the mark of joint attention by misguided professionals, as though joint attention automatically comes with the verbal interaction. But it's not the kind of interaction that parents crave, at least it wasn't for us. I'd call it verbal faux-interaction instead of something real.

I can tell you from experience that you can create a very verbal child who has little-to-no experience with interaction. Using HaberkornHalm's list almost as a 'recipe book' of sorts, you can 'get' your child to 'talk', 'request', 'mand', 'demand'. But all of those things can occur outside of real reciprocity, outside of the non-verbal dance of turn-taking, outside of true interaction. How do I know that, you wonder? I know that because it happened at my house.

Be careful with lists of "19 ways".

Before I learned about developmental foundations through folks like the ones from Relationship Development Intervention or Communicating Partners, I would have used that list for more one-sided manding, not for reciprocity and interaction.

"But Penny," you may be wondering, the author mentions specific non-verbal actions, why are you picking on this? After all, HaberkornHalm writes, "Make sure the child wants or needs the item (looks at, reaches for, points to, tries to get it) or the action."

Looking at, reaching for, pointing to, trying to get it can ALL be one-sided mands and not functions of interaction and reciprocity. Using the ABLLS, we taught all of those actions as mands and checked them off the list. Many years later, as I studied the development of joint attention, I realized that looking at, reaching for, pointing to, trying to get are much, much more than mere mands, they're early non-verbal pre-cursers (Dr Gutstein calls them "prototypes") of joint attention. We severely limited our child by giving her the experience that they are only mands. I am still upset over the way we merrily checked them off the ABLLS checklist as though we'd captured the full developmental meaning behind them when we'd taught them only as a mand.

Looking back at our journey, I see red flags all over these recommendations for increasing verbal interactions for families who are in the same shoes that I was in a few years ago. My kid could request, verbally and non-verbally, but she could not interact. For us, "talk" and lists of ways to increase verbal interaction had REPLACED the underdeveloped joint attention and underdeveloped non-verbal foundations of speech. That list would not have helped me give my girl the things I really wanted her to have without an understanding of how joint attention develops via interaction with a parent, something both RDI(r) and CP have taught me.

Our experience, like many others, is that focusing on non-verbal foundations of communication/joint attention/theory of mind has increased verbal interaction as a by-product. I never imagined that giving up a focus on "talk" and "increasing verbal interaction" and instead focusing on pre-speech foundations would actually INCREASE speech and receptive language. But it did!!! Another by-product that we saw happen without directly targeting it as a behavior to change was the eloping and bolting behavior decreased the more she was non-verbally "with" us in terms of joint attention. (I called our then-consultant from a department store one afternoon and asked, "What is happening? She is staying with me without my hanging on to her wrist with all my might." He chuckled and told me that he was hearing that a lot from his families.)

So, if you have a child who is verbal and mostly (all) one-sided, like I did, here's a suggestion for you. Use the list to give your child practice and experience in non-verbal referencing, in non-verbal turn-taking and interaction with you, and let go of the need to "get" more words and talk and instead give them experience in the benefits of a relationship with mom or dad.

Here's an example:

When you take a different action that you usually do, for example, handing the child an empty toothbrush instead of one loaded with toothpaste, you give the child an opportunity to reference you both physically, with a glance or look (not "eye contact", but referencing for meaning, and those two things are very different!) and to reference you mentally, wondering what is in your mind. For a child on the autism spectrum, who has little experience with the idea that there could be something different in YOUR mind than their is in HIS mind, this is a preliminary step in giving him experience with that kind of joint attention. Allow him processing time to take his own glance at you to see what you're up to, be quiet and wait, and when he notices, don't try to "get" something else (a verbal request) from him; you don't have wait for him to mand for the toothpaste. Be silly and answer, "I forgot the toothpaste!" Use it as an opportunity to squirt the toothpaste together.

Honestly, my kid who could mand for toothpaste could not reference and interact. Her expressive communication far outweighed her interactive world. If your kid sounds like that, you need to approach a list like this one aimed at "verbal interaction" with caution.

HaberkornHalm's list is a good one, but I'd like to qualify that it is for children who have non-verbal foundations of speech firmly in place, and for many kids with developmental delays, "special needs", autism, etc., the list needs another title. I'd rename it, "19 Ways to Create Opportunities for Your Child to Practice and Experience Referencing You For Meaning And Joining You in Interactions As Part Experience With You in Early Stages of Joint Attention".

Sunday, February 27, 2011

Please & Thank You

Just a few days ago, I witnessed an event that is relatively common in autism and special needs circles that used to be a 'normal' event for me, one that is now appalling to me.

Child was prompted to say "please" when requesting an item, and prompted again to say "thank you" when the child was given that item. Mom helped by guiding child's head toward therapist. (I wrote about that here.) The therapist with the item "helped" by reminding the child to tell her eyes "thank you".

What's so horrible about that, you may wonder? Manners are a good thing.

Manners are a good thing, but let's help our children experience manners within a context of real reciprocity, the full package of communication, non-verbal and verbal/words/"talk".

The child was not given an opportunity to orient her body or her gaze toward the gift giver, was not given an opportunity to reply on her own. Those opportunities were stolen. Worse, the child was not expected to be able to do those things. (Why are parents taught to behave this way with kids on the autism spectrum, anyway?)

"Please" and "thank you" are soooooooo much more than three little memorized (rote) words and meaningless eye contact. Teaching a child on the autism spectrum that "please" and "thank you" are only about eye contact and saying the right words is not only short sided, it is giving the child a completely different experience than the rest of the world gets.

Let's quit ignoring reciprocity at non-verbal levels when we think about, work with kids on the autism spectrum. Please. Thank you.

As a parent, I did not understand this at all until RDI(r) came along for me almost seven years ago. None of the professionals in my life understood it, either, much like the therapist in red scrubs who thought she was "helping". Why is a developmental approach still so rare? Why do so few therapists and teachers understand this?

Being a competent responder of prompts does not = the interaction and reciprocity that children on the autism spectrum need to practice and experience for themselves. Being a competent responder of prompts does not = the interaction we parents long for. You can't get there from here.

The therapist would have impressed me had she used an experience sharing statement, like, "I'm over here."coupled with plenty of processing and response time instead of a direct prompt demanding an immediate response with empty, meaningless eye contact in the directive, "tell it to my eyes".

*cringe*

Our children need practice and experience in interdependence, interaction, reciprocity, turn taking, etc, at non-verbal levels, first. The basic non-verbal dance steps are critical to the later steps. Feeling self taking an action in concert with other is one of the basic foundations, and that cannot be experienced by following prompts. You can't get there from here. If you as the parent or therapist is doing both sides of the dance for the child with autism, you are creating learned helplessness: I don't have to hold up my side, non-verbal and verbal, of the interaction, because someone will directly prompt me when needed.

I won't be using that therapist or sending my child to her summer camp program. You probably guessed that.

And if you're interested in reading more about my journey, away from prompting, toward non-verbal foundations of interaction, start with the label "learned helplessness" (lefthand side bar of my blog).

Saturday, September 4, 2010

CONVERSATION, The Key To Success / The Wisdom of "Dr Jim"

Today's blog entry comes from "Dr. Jim", aka, Dr. James D. MacDonald.

CONVERSATION
The Key to Success

Especially for persons with developmental delays such as Autism, Aspergers, Down syndrome, Motor and Attention disorders.

Dr. James D. MacDonald
Professor emeritus, Ohio State University
The Communicating Partners Center, Columbus, Ohio

A personal letter to anyone concerned about someone with problems having conversations.

Imagine a life without conversations. Imagine being isolated from the world without the basic rules of conversation. Imagine having few or no friends because conversation is not easy, natural or enjoyable for you. Imagine having worked hard to learn a lot in school but few around you realize it since a lack of conversations creates a wall between you and society.

Sounds pretty terrible, no?

I know a great many persons who live such lives without conversation. They include both children and adults. Many are persons who are "late to talk" or diagnosed with Autism, Asperger's syndrome, Down syndrome, Neurological and motor disorders, ADD-ADHD, Environmental deprivation and other conditions limiting conversations. Many are typical children who fall through the social cracks without conversational skills and miss much learning and social progress.

I know many persons who succeeded in learning language, only to be just as isolated as they were without language. Why? They did not know how to have conversations. All that hard work learning language may have paid off in schoolwork but not in a real social life. Language without conversation can be like a Mercedes car without gas. Conversation is the key to your child 's learning, socializing, and being truly included.

THINK ABOUT THIS: Consider everything you know and use in daily life---then, ask yourself: How much of that did I learn in school or direct teaching and how much did I learn in daily interactions with life partners? I know that I learn much more from conversations than from direct teaching.

Traditional educational, therapeutic and behavioral programs work very hard teaching children to learn facts, repair problems, and behave acceptably. Unfortunately, little serious attention is usually paid to teaching the conversation skills essential for successful personal and work relationships. Communicating Partners is a program committed to helping every person, regardless of their delays to have a CONVERSATIONAL LIFE.

ALARMING FINDINGS AND MYTHS ABOUT CONVERSATION.

Our 30+years of clinical research reveal several disturbing findings (MacDonald, 2004; MacDonald and Mitchell, 2002) and unsupported beliefs that keep our children from conversational lives.

1. Many believe conversations require a lot of language.
2. School programs require conversation skills for success.
3. Many expect conversations come automatically with language.
4. Consequently, there are very few direct efforts to teach conversation.
5. Many accept questions/answer routines and monologues as satisfactory conversations.
6. Without conversations, people appear less competent than they are.
7. Many do not believe that conversation skills can be learned.
8. Many are unaware that children learn more in conversations than in school.
9. Conversations are often discouraged in education and therapy.
10. Conversation skills are rarely taught in school or therapy.

FINDINGS THAT PROVE THE ASSUMPTIONS WRONG.

Widespread research findings show the above assumptions to be untrue and actually harmful to a child's development. Those research and clinical findings support the conclusions below that are the bases of the Communicating Partners approach to Conversation learning.

1. Fundamental conversation skills can be learned long before speech: the earlier they are learned, the easier a conversation life develops.

2. Many interventions and schools teach cognitive, behavioral and adaptive skills when the children lack conversation skills to put the skills to use in daily life. Without conversation skills, that learning is stored away and wasted.

3. Many educational approaches actually train children to NOT have conversations as a key part of their learning. When children are discouraged from interacting they cannot become conversational.

4. Conversations do not automatically come with language; many children have elaborate language but poor conversation skills,and many are as isolated as when they had no language

5. We cannot consider any assessment of a child's intelligence or other competencies if child has poor conversation skills.Consequently, conversation skills will reveal the real child. Remember, conversation begins at birth, so we are talking about any meaningful social exchange as a conversation. Question assessments that do not include easy playful interactions.

6. Conversations simply mean going back and forth meaningfully with partners with any behaviors-actions, sounds, as well as words. Consequently, children need to learn conversation rules long before they talk. ---Rules such as Initiating and Responding to people, Playing more with people than things, Imitating and modeling others, Turntaking and Taking the other person's perspective. Each of these skills can begin very early in life, when their life partners enter the child's world.

7. Partners must help children have conversations with actions and sounds first-Without that learning children are likely to use language mainly to satisfy needs and perform. And real relationships do not happen that way.

8. Conversation can be learned as well as other social skills: The five responsive strategies of Communicating Partners are the key to becoming conversational. Many parents have helped children have conversational vs. isolated lives.

9. Clearly we learn and retain much more information that we get from daily conversations than from being directly taught. The social process makes learning more lasting and enjoyable.

10. Children learn much more in social contacts than in academic or behavioral drills, especially when those contacts are conversational. Do not expect your child to learn conversations in school. One to one intimate interactions are needed.

11. And remember, the major problem in for our children is SOCIAL ISOLATION AND LONELINESS, not lack of school-learning. Consequently, if INCLUSION is what you want for your child, CONVERSATIONS ARE THE KEY not academic learning.

For practical programs for building conversational lives, see
COMMUNICATING PARTNERS.: www.jamesdmacdonald.org
E-mail: macdonald.3@osu.edu
and
the key book: Communicating Partners ( Amazon.com etc)

Monday, April 19, 2010

To The Three Teens Blocking the Slide On the Playground Tonight

Dear Teens,

We were at the ball park to watch my son play baseball. Tonight was his first game of the season, and he was the starting pitcher. I'm so proud of him! He works hard, and his hard work pays off. He's a good little player for a 10-year-old! His development has happened so naturally, so uneventfully, and he's able to put his mind to something and work toward it.

I made sure to arrive early tonight so I wouldn't miss a pitch or his first at-bat.

My baseball player's twin sister has autism. She has a hard time at the ball park. She begs to go to the playground. Doesn't matter what fun activities I bring for her to do at the field; she begs loudly to go to the park. And begs. And screeches. We're working on that, but I can't work on it with her at a little boys' ball game with a playscape staring right at us. There's an attention deficit component, where she can't think of anything else. And a self-control component, where she can't stop herself from asking again and again if she can go to the playground. Autism is different, and I've learned over time that we work on development of self-regulation and self-control at home, and we see the fruits of it when we're not at home. She's made a lot of progress. Instead of being like a baby, she's more like a preschooler, now. That's huge. And we're still moving forward. :)

Playgrounds are a magnet for younger children. In some ways, this daughter is like a preschooler. She enjoys the playground and the younger children who also like playgrounds. The playscape is something she can't do at home. We don't have a playscape at home - the sets for big kids start at $3K, and when you're paying for autism therapy out of pocket, (it is not covered by insurance) you can't always budget $3K+ for a playscape for your back yard.

Being with younger children is good experience for her, navigating around one another, watching out for the little kids, negotiating turns on equipment. The playground is directly behind our game field, tonight. I allow her to go with her big sister.

Let me tell you about my baseball player's twin sister. Maybe some background will help with context. You see, she regressed into autism after their first birthday. I watched her stop babbling. I thought she'd gone deaf. She quit responding to her name, quit interacting with me, quit paying attention to me. A year later, she had a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder.

We didn't know if she would speak. And then she began to speak - expressively. The same words she could say, she could not understand. We knew that because we were using a behavioral program from behavioral psychology to teach her, and that behavioral program charted all of her progress. She could identify words going in one direction (expressive), but not the other (receptive). It was as if she was able to speak (pronounce all the words, having memorized many words and phrases) a foreign language but not understand a word she was saying.

She became a one sided word machine. I longed for interaction, dialogue, conversation. Instead I heard entire stories or cartoons, from beginning to end, which she could recite in perfect prosody, and without missing a syllable. But she couldn't have a conversation. Until then, I had no idea that a child could acquire hundreds of words and not be able to interact in 2-way communication. I didn't understand, then, about levels of joint attention and I didn't understand the importance of non-verbal foundations of communication. I didn't understand the idea of a developmental age.

When she was five, with the help of developmental psychology, and new professionals to guide us, we realized that she was missing basics of interaction. She had no reciprocity, no back-and-forth, no turn-taking at non-verbal levels. I learned that she couldn't have a verbal conversation because she couldn't have a non-verbal conversation. Non-verbal conversations come first in development. We still spend time practicing non-verbal interaction with her.

Fast forward to tonight. I let her go to the playground with her older sister to keep an eye on her at close range. I can read the non-verbal communication on that playscape from my position beside the field, because the playscape is directly behind the field on which my son's team is playing. I can see the playground from my position and can be there quickly if I am needed. I can see from my chair at the ball field that you teenagers are blocking the slide and that my daughter with autism is attempting to use the slide. My older daughter's body language shows me she's uncomfortable with the situation that she's watching from the ground. I leave my son's game (while he is still pitching) to see if I need to help my girl navigate the roadblock you've created with your bodies. When I am close enough to hear her, I notice my younger girl is scripting a lot, reciting the same lines over and over, some from TV shows. She does that when she's anxious. Your teenage presence x3 is the primary source of her anxiety at this moment. Surely you notice this unusual behavior, too. Don't you suspect she might have a disability?

I see the three of you, two teen girls and a boy, clean cut, attractive, pleasant looking kids, on top of a platform that leads to three parts of the playscape, the slide, a swirly ladder, and a fireman pole. You three are taking up most of the platform, and specifically blocking the entrance to the slide. You three are in the way in a high-traffic area atop the playscape. (What in your minds makes you believe this is even polite?)

As the playscape became more crowded with little kids, what kept you from thinking or acting upon the thought, "We should move. We're taking up all the room up here and making it difficult for the little kids who love slides to access it." The fact that you did not get down on your own made me reluctant to ask you to take your important conversation somewhere else. I suspected you would defend your right to be there and the situation would get worse. And I hate confrontations.

I decide to say nothing. My daughter must learn to navigate obstacles like you pose on her own. Will she ask you to move? I don't know. I do know that if I jump in for her every time, she'll never get experience, and she needs experience. And she's capable of managing the nonverbal communication involved in approaching the slide (with intent to slide - I know you teens are able to understand the intent in her actions) and waiting for someone to move out of her way. Except she's not ready, from a developmental standpoint, to be around teens like you, strangers at the park, behaving like alpha dogs establishing territory among a bunch of little kids.

I'm guessing you felt pretty dawggone smug with yourselves. If I said something to you, you'd probably say, "We're not stopping the kids from sliding." No, not with your mouths or spoken language. However, your very presence in that spot at the top of the playscape spoke something else (non-verbally) to the children and to me and my older daughter. Your actions and behaviors are rich in meaning.

We've been to two parks in recent days, where there were no teens. I blogged about our visits here and here. When we're at the park with littles, I see how far she's come. The passive-aggressive situation you gave her tonight is a completely different animal.

I watch my daughter climb the stairs, step onto the platform, and approach the slide. Her non-verbal communication indicates she wants to slide down the slide. Occasionally, the teen blocking the slide will step aside to allow my daughter through, but not often. Your non-verbal communication, rich with meaning and intent, says "no", or you were passive-aggressively thinking, "you'll have to ask me first" in an unspoken game of "Mother May I?" that a child with developmental delays is unable to navigate. Either way, you teens are bullies. Soft bullying is still bullying. And my daughter has not experienced that, yet, and has no idea how to navigate a trio of teenage bullies who are head and shoulders above all the other children on that playground. I watched and studied the situation. Almost every time she tried to enter the slide and encountered you, she retreated and went down another way. I could see her talking as she approached you, and it sounded like scripting to me. (She scripts when she's anxious. The professional term is "delayed echolalia".) Your body language told me you were talking about her, and not being kind.

She was almost always the only child on the playscape who attempted to climb the platform and use the slide. Occasionally one of the little kids there tried to slide, but they mostly stayed away from the platform where the three of you stood together. To little kids, you're big. Intimidating.

Once, I saw a really little girl climb up there, and you were blocking that slide, so she tried to go down the fireman's pole. One of you reacted swiftly, called her by name, ordered her not to go down that way. She tried anyway, and you grabbed her from danger. Ironic that your bully stance created a problem for one of the children you apparently knew.

In your minds, you were innocent - just talking - yet you'd staked out the most popular piece of real estate for little kids at the ballpark - for YOURSELVES to have an hour long conversation. Why were you at the ballpark? Was someone in your family playing ball? You're big enough to self-regulate and watch a game. Why weren't you doing that instead of planting yourselves on the playscape with a "we got here first" attitude?

You were out of place - you had no business being there, unless you were a part of the action, playing with, babysitting, interacting with, chasing little kids, lifting them up to reach the monkey bars. You were doing none of that - you were simply having a stand-up-on-this-platform-and-block-the-way-down-pow-wow in a place built for younger kids to play on. (Seriously, how many times do you see teens playing on a playscape?)

I watched. My older daughter watched. She was upset by your behavior, murmured to me that she didn't understand why you kept taking up all the room and blocking the slide.

I chose to say nothing, until I saw a woman, the mother of one of you, come from a ball field and climb the stairs, heard you tell her that the woman in the sunglasses (me) was staring at you, tell her what my daughter said to you. (Did you call your mother from your cell phone to tattle on my daughter or on me?)

I didn't hear my daughter, but I learned later that the exact line she told one of the girls was, "Your outfit is soooooooooooo last year."

That line is from a TV show (Hannah Montana, if you're wondering). A TV show where the teens who are friends cut one another down and get big laughs. I've told her not to say that line. Yet, I can't stop her from saying it. To my daughter with autism, I think, it is something acceptable that big kids (teens) say to one another. They say it on that TV show, and everyone laughs. She doesn't understand the meaning and context of it outside of a TV show. Maybe she was pretending to BE IN a TV show, and she didn't understand why you didn't laugh like the actress in the show.

So I explained to you three and the mom, she has autism, we didn't know if she would ever talk, she is talking now, and yet, she's still has a lot to learn about social appropriateness. I apologized for her. And by the way, you're too big to be up here, would you please get down, she can't navigate her way through all your body language.

I descended the platform, took my place on the sidelines, to keep an eye on my daughter.

The mom of one of the girls followed me, and told me a thing or two. Her voice was calm, so was mine. This was not a particularly heated exchange, but it was not pleasant.

One thing she told me is the playground belongs to everyone and the teens have a right to be up on that platform. (Come on, I'll ask again, when do you see teens playing on a playscape? Uh, NEVER. It is not a cool place for teens. Socially inappropriate. I wasn't referring to their "rights". I was referring to "appropriateness".)

PS: It's a PLAYscape or PLAYground.

Not a STANDscape or STANDground.

What did I want them to be doing, she asked me, out vandalizing cars?

(Are they vandals, I wondered?)

(I wished I'd asked the mom if the teens ever learned how to *share*. That's one skill kids practice on a playscape.)

She informed me that she has a nephew who is autistic and that he is non-verbal, has never said a word, and that he is 10 years old, and that if MY daughter can TALK, that means SHE CAN COMMUNCIATE, and that she was INSULTING her daughter ON PURPOSE.

And because my daughter can talk, that mom informed me, she should have ASKED them to move each time she wanted to slide. She did ask, with her body language. And the teens' very presence in a place they didn't belong was intimidating to her and their body language said, 'no'. My daughter did not understand the complex unspoken rules your daughter and the other two teens had established there.

Why didn't your daughter ask my child,

"Do you want to slide?"

She told me that I'm not a good parent to allow my child to insult someone's outfit.

You have no idea what kind of parent I am.

She went on and on about how being able to speak equals full and total communication.

You are so wrong.

She accused me of trying to make her teen feel guilty after my child insulted her without apology.

We never got an apology for the behavior of the teens.

Mom of teen girl: I appreciate the "mama-bear" in you. But you're way off base, defending soft bullying. And I understand, you were somewhere watching a game, not watching your teen. Teens don't have to be monitored for safety like my child does. What you didn't see was how long they'd been up there, what they were doing when approached by younger children, you missed the soft bullying there.

Mom of teen girl, YOU HAVE NO CLUE. YOU HAVE NO IDEA what communication is. You're making too many assumptions that are not true. Behavior is communication, and tonight, my daughter's behavior communicated anxiety and not knowing a good way to approach a wall of teens blocking the slide. (Your daughter's behavior expressed soft bullying.) The communication you assume that my daughter has because she can talk assumes a higher level of joint attention than you even begin to understand, lady.

Mom: Words don't always = the 2-way communication that you think it does; echolalia (delayed echolalia in this case) does not = an insult. Having a 10 year old non-verbal nephew with autism does not make you an expert about all things autism. You know nothing about my daughter (that's why I'm trying to explain it to you, yet you seem to be incapable of understanding and perspective taking. Your joint attention needs some practice.) I have a 10 year old verbal daughter with autism who copes by memorizing laugh lines from TV shows - and by knowing that about my daughter, I can't presume to know anything about your nephew.

Mom: let's trade. Your daughter can have the kind of autism that mine does. Mine can be neurotypical. I promise you, my daughter would not be on the playground blocking the equipment meant for younger children.

And teens, your behavior tonight was a form of bullying, judging and picking on someone weaker than you, someone vulnerable. You need to recognize that. Own up to it. Accept responsibility. Apologize. Make a better choice next time.

You feel smug and innocent because you didn't TELL her verbally that she couldn't slide. Yet, you bullied with rich meaning and communication at non-verbal levels.

Hey, I'VE GOT AN IDEA! Let's have a big meeting, invite some friends! There's a doctor's office down the street - let's meet in his patient waiting room. It's small. It won't matter that we're that we're taking up chairs meant for patients, even the wheelchair in the waiting room. It doesn't matter that we're pushing the boundary of appropriate - after all - we have a right to be there! Some of us are the doctor's patients, and all of us could be if we wanted to. The idea that the chairs are for patients with appointments is implied, and we'll ignore that, because we have a right to be here. So, here's the rule: IF A PATIENT ASKS ONE OF US FOR A SEAT, WE WILL GET UP AND GIVE OUR SEAT TO THAT PERSON. But we won't have to unless we're asked with spoken words. We won't talk to anyone outside of our group, won't ask if we can help them, won't offer anyone a seat - we need to have our meeting, after all. We'll ignore all non-verbal communication from patients who throw disgusting looks our way, patients who sigh. We'll ignore people who complain verbally to one another. If we are asked in direct, spoken words to move, we'll do so willingly. IF someone with an injury, both feet in casts, for example, complains that we didn't get out of the wheelchair, we'll tell him, "You have feet, that means don't need a chair because you can stand or walk around!"

The mom did ask the teens to leave the playscape, and for that I am thankful. At some level, the mom understood that the teens did not belong there from a socially appropriate standpoint. The little kids were happy, too - they *swarmed* the slide, their behavior told me they were absolutely thrilled they had access to it (finally). The mood at the playscape was completely different when the teens left the perch.

When I was a teen, if I had been one of the three on that platform, blocking the slide for nearly an hour, my parents would have admonished me for being to big to be on a playscape for little kids; they would have sent me somewhere appropriate. My parents would not have defended me by saying, "she has a right to be there".

Times have changed.

And autism is so misunderstood.

In case you're wondering, my daughter did not script lines from videos or talk about the outfits of any of the little kids at our recent park days. Her anxiety was low, there, with no intimidating kids like you, there.

Did I make my daughter apologize to the teen girl? No. I didn't learn what my daughter said until I had the conversation with the mom and the teens had vacated the playscape (hopefully not to vandalize cars).

And yes, on the way home, I talked to her again about how that line from the TV show is NOT appropriate, that she hurt a girl's feelings, and asked her not to say it again. Will she be able to stop herself from saying it the next time she sees a teen who reminds her of that TV show? I don't know. Only time will tell. We're still working on the perspective taking and self-control pieces.

PS to my READERS: Be sure to keep reading the next few posts as I think through this incident.

# # #

Here is a picture I took of that playscape four games later - no teens up high, blocking the slide!

Thursday, February 25, 2010

Theory of Mind. Joint Attention. Intersubjectivity.

Aut-2B-Home in Carolina blogger Tammy Glaser blogged an insightful post about intersubjectivity yesterday.

She has me remembering the first time I saw the term "theory of mind" where someone defined it for me. I attended a workshop about Floortime by beloved PLAY Project expert Dr Richard Solomon, and one of the slides was about theory of mind.

I remember coming away from the presentation with the idea that "theory of mind" mysteriously comes upon most children and not on children with autism. Dr Solomon didn't give me the progression of development that explained how theory of mind (joint attention) (intersubjectivity) develops. (Maybe he did and I simply don't remember it -- I can tell you I didn't come away with any understanding of it, other than people on the autism spectrum don't acquire it.)

It wasn't until Dr Gustein lectured on the developmental levels of intersubjectivity that I realized that theory of mind doesn't simply happen or not happen -- it grows via a distinct and thoroughly documented set of stages via experience with another person, usually Mom and Dad, and yes, parents have an opportunity to go back in development and "do over" the steps and levels of intersubjectivity with a child on the autism spectrum (or Down Syndrome or other developmental delay) and see the child grow (naturally) in theory of mind.

(FYI: I attempted to provide my understanding of how intersubjectivity develops in the post I wrote about why I finally decided to homeschool.)

If you're wondering whether the "theory-of-mind" fairy is going to come upon your child w/ asd, you don't have to wonder. You are the key to the re-do.

Thanks Tammy, for the descriptive example of intersubjectivity at the post office on your blog.

Friday, January 22, 2010

Consequences of Adults Talking Too Much by Dr James MacDonald

Wish I had met Dr Jim much earlier in my daughter's journey.




PARTNER TALKS SO MUCH THE CHILD GETS TOO LITTLE PRACTICE.

Why is this a problem?:
Not enough practice for a conversation habit.
Learns to be passive.
Learns to talk only about others ideas.
Fails to learn turn-taking.
Believes his ideas are not important.
Partner usually gives talking models that are too complicated.
Conversation are short lived when one person runs the show.
CONVERSATION LEADS TO A SOCIAL LIFE MORE THAN LANGUAGE ITSELF.

What can you do to help?

THINK OF CONVERSATION AS A GIVE AND TAKE, A PING-PONG
GAME NOT A LECTURE OR A TEST.
Wait silently for partner to have his turn.
Clearly expect and anticipate him to participate.
Allow his turn at times to be physical and nonverbal.
Accept and respond to a turn even if it is unclear.
Let person know that you want the conversation to continue.
Remind your self that he will learn more when you do only half.
Your child learns language best in conversations.
Make conversation out of physical interactions.

EXAMPLE:
LESS LIKE THIS

MOM: Your birthday’s coming. What do you think you will get? I bet Grandma will get you clothes again. Who will get you toys? What toys do you want?
Child: Computer games. The ones that...
M: Interrupting. Oh not more of those. you just hide way and get stuck on those.
C: You can play with me on the computer.
M: Oh you know I am always busy. And I don’t understand what you see in them.
C: You could learn.
M: Oh I have too much to do.


EXAMPLE
MORE LIKE THIS:

MOM: Birthday’s coming. Waits looking at child.
Child: I want a train cake. With an engine and a caboose.
M: Any tender cars?
C: Yes one for pigs and horses.
M: They might fight together.
C: Okay, lets have two tender cars.



CONVERSATIONS DEVELOP BEST WHEN BOTH PARTNERS PARTICIPATE AS MUCH AS THE OTHER.
THE CHILD LEARNS MORE LANGUAGE TOO.
James D.MacDonald

From the yahoo group "communicating", a list comprised of parents and professionals who are currently utilizing or are interested in helping children with various learning disAbilities learn to communicate effectively by using the methods of Dr. James D. MacDonald of "Communicating Partners." Dr Jim generously allows members to share his tips and advice with others. Thank you, Dr Jim!

Thursday, December 31, 2009

Non-verbal Communication: Conversations Using *Only* Faces

I like to write about the a-ha moments that stand out for me, the moments where a concept really began to sink in. I hope my anecdotes help you to look at autism intervention in a new way. I wish that someone had told me about some of these developmental concepts much sooner. Here's a story from my journal:

Two years ago, one of our RDI(r) objectives involved the concept of having conversations using just our faces. There are other ways to communicate non-verbally, but we needed to spend time on faces at that particular point in time.

When we are assigned a new objective by our RDI(r) Program Certified Consultant, I have to ponder it for a few days, and I usually begin seeing evidence of the objective all around me, which helps me understand it's importance in a do-over.

Within a day or so of being assigned this particular objective (which is more specific than the version I summarized for you, here), I was driving the sibs to school, slowing down to make a right turn onto the street of the elementary school. That corner is quite busy, and there are children walking to school who cross that street from two different directions.

I've noticed over time (episodic memory) that the crossing guard stays in the warm comfort of her van until she is needed to escort children across the street, and if the crossing guard is standing outside her van, I can follow her gaze (perspective taking, attention shifting) and tell from which direction the students are walking.

One morning, the crossing guard was unusually close to the street, and her position alerted me to the idea that there were probably children approaching the crosswalk, and the silent conversation began.

I slowed down, prepared to make my right turn, and could tell from the direction of her gaze where the children were coming from, and they were pretty close to crossing the street where I was about to make my turn. So I had to shift my attention back to her, intentionally look to her, using my face to ask an unspoken but extremely important question, and receive an answer from her face and gestures. Was she going to let me go first, or was she going to have me stop, and let the children go first? We had to have a conversation using just our faces. She had to know that I saw her, that I would stop, before she would let the children cross the street.

Once I recognized several examples in my day where I relied on faces for conversation, I was ready to tackle the assignment and make some discoveries of my own. When a child doesn't take the initiative to monitor facial expressions, like I had to monitor the face of the crossing guard, the parents and professionals around that child behave differently, and we tend to overcompensate. I had to learn to quit feeding learned helplessness, use myself in new ways, so that my daughter could make some new discoveries.

What a different journey the developmental path has been...


PS: If you own the DVD version of the movie, Cars, check out the bonus feature called, "One Man Band". Count the number of verbal exchanges and the number of non-verbal, faces-only exchanges. It's quite an education for such a short film and worth renting or borrowing from the library if you don't own the DVD.
OnePlusYou Quizzes and Widgets

Created by OnePlusYou -

Stat Counter